The Windmill

This traditional Mayfair pub is renowned for its real ale and pub food, in particular its selection of homemade pies. Read More


This traditional Mayfair pub is renowned for its real ale and pub food, in particular its selection of homemade pies that are served upstairs in its dedicated pie room.

Venue Details & Map

The Windmill

6-8 Mill Street
+44 (0)20 7491 8050
Public transport:
Oxford Circus, Underground

Yelp Reviews

8.00 out of 5
based on 72 reviews

Top 5 reviews of The Windmill

4.0 out of 5
31 May 2017
by Michael K.

Comfortable pub, great pies.

Perfect place to escape the rain for an hour and think about nothing.

I recommend the lamb pie. The suet crust was flaky and delicious, and the star of the dish. more

5.0 out of 5
27 April 2017
by Elizabeth T.

Steak and Mushroom pie.

This little beauty was quite simply the most delicious pie I've eaten. The pastry was flaky on the outside and warm and soft on the inside with a rich thick gravy and satisfying chunks of beef. Beware the whole bay leaf, be glad it's so wonderfully flavored!

The teeny pot of gravy was on its own delicious, when added to the pie helped take it to another level.

A lot... more

4.0 out of 5
09 December 2017
by Michael Y.

There's others, so make sure you've got the right Windmill!

This is absolutely the right Windmill. It turned out to be the perfect way to hide away from the snow. My wife and I shared the steak and mushroom pie, and I almost left her so I could spend the rest of my days with the chef, happily being hand-fed pies until gravy flows through my veins and I die of over-consumption. This was a... more

5.0 out of 5
17 February 2018
by Daniel T.

Best Shepherd's pie I have ever had. Crust was very flaky, this place is a must go if you are in the area. Perfect meal after a cold day of sightseeing. Great atmosphere, I will be back for another pie. Steak and mushroom pie is also delicious. more

4.0 out of 5
25 November 2017
by D. P.

Best shepherds pie...good amount of savory lamb and some minced vegetables topped with mashed potatoes and a small side of greens. Wish they had slightly more mashed potatoes, but the container was filled to the top and I wouldn't want them to reduce the meat portion for it.

It's also a cool bar with lots of locals just drinking and smoking. I was there at 6pm on a Tuesday evening and it was... more

Is The Windmill your business?

Find out how to become a Partner to enhance your listing and access other benefits.

Look for similar items by category