Melanie Italian Restaurant

Book Now

Reserve table

Instant free table reservation


Typical meal price: From £25.00 (USD31.66) per diner

£25 and under

Venue Details & Map

Melanie Italian Restaurant

4 - 6 Old Compton Street

Yelp Reviews

2.5 out of 5 based on 14 reviews

Top 5 reviews of Melanie Italian Restaurant

2.0 out of 5 17 October 2016
by Bevin M.

We felt really lucky to find a last minute table on a weekend night in the heart of Soho, so I can say at least we were inside and sitting down. Menu had a lot of choices and many were vegetarian- yea! We got a couple bottles of house wine for the table and it was good. The garlic bread with cheese was like an open face grilled cheese and very yummy. I had a spicy lightly dressed spaghetti...more

2.0 out of 5 10 September 2016
by Angela N.

Had a pre theatre dinner here as it's located very close to prince Edward Theatre. Had starters of king prawns and calamari. Big portions and I was satisfied with the starters. Sadly, I was unimpressed with the chef's special of spaghetti meatballs! Meatballs were so dry! And not much sauce with it. It was rather disappointing.more

5.0 out of 5 13 October 2015
by Connie C.

The service was always spot on and the food was delicious. We went there as the last customers of the night and it felt like "be our guest" scene from beauty and the beast. The food was fresh and delicious and I eat everywhere in NYC. I don't understand why there are such low ratings. I prefer the food over the pizza but, the pizza was a quick purchase which was very convenient before we...more

2.0 out of 5 28 August 2015
by Eric K.

Although we requested a good table in our booking, we were seated at the back of the restaurant. Prices were very reasonable. Ordered wine, just cold enough but then they put an ice cover around it, which was not frozen so pointless, which meant the wine soon got warm.

Starter of bruchetta and calamarie: Bruchetta was very poor 4/10, calamari was ok 6/10.

Mains: the tuna steak was badly...more

1.0 out of 5 16 May 2015
by Armony H.

I went there with a friend on Friday night. I was not impressed by the food or wine.

First we were quite surprise it wasn't busy at all, but now I understand.

I decided to have a glass of house red and my friend ordered a jameson and coke. I got a glass of wine (you may want to call it vinegar as it was really disgusting). They brought a glass of whiskey and ice with no coke to my friend....more

Look for similar items by category

Is Melanie Italian Restaurant your business?

Find out how to become a Partner to enhance your listing and access other benefits.